Saturday, November 22, 2008

Disappearing Acts

Have you ever sat in a room full of people but felt that, if questioned the next day, no one in the audience would recall you being there? Or, maybe you heard something so incongruous and while you thought you were shouting at the top of your lungs to contest it, there was actually no sound emanating from your mouth? If the answer to either of these questions is yes, then you will know what it was like for me today at the 40-day memorial service organized by Cindy's family in Virginia Beach.

According to tradition, this type of service is held 40 days after a death, mirroring the period between the resurrection and ascension of Christ. About twenty of us traveled down from the Washington, DC-area to attend the service. We had no idea what to expect.

The priest began his homily talking about the importance of home, family, and marriage. When he got more specific about Cindy's life, he said that although she was not "married" and did not have a "home," she still lived a good life (apparently a home is made when a woman marries a man and has at least 1 child). During the homily, I turned to my friend and said, "Uh, didn't Cindy and I have a home?" I mean, we never had a kid, but we had 2 godchildren, a niece and a nephew, a dog, a cat, and about 11 koi fish in our pond. And, we may not have been married according to the law, but I'm pretty sure we lived like one. I mean, she often got mad at me for scratching the wood floors, for not drying off my feet before stepping onto the bath mat, and for always getting lost while driving. That's standard operating procedure for most married couples, right?

Throughout the homily, I was shaking my head left and right. This couldn't be happening to me. Why couldn't I stand up and shout, "She did have a HOME and it was with ME!" I mean I used to be a Lesbian Avenger, but here I was sitting quietly and watching my existence for the last several years get erased. These kinds of disappearing acts were a popular theme in melodramatic gay movies from the 80s, but they could not be re-occurring in this day and age, right?

I am sure the priest asked some basic questions of the family before today, but it was obvious he had no idea who I was to Cindy. I was not mentioned during the intercessions, nor was I acknowledged by the family during the part where you say "peace be with you" to your neighbors. I might as well have been a stranger who walked in off the street to sit in on the memorial service of a random person.

People tell me, "Oh Jen, don't worry. No one can take away who you were to Cindy. No one can erase the great memories you had together." But, I want more than just the mental relics. Why couldn't I have also had public and legal acknowledgment of who Cindy and I were to each other for all these years? And when it comes down to it, it's a cop out to only accept our own memories. Memories are not enough anymore. This is about a public consciousness. This is about altering our definitions of family, home, and marriage. This is about expanding the vernacular.

9 comments:

Heather Benza said...

oh Jen I'm so sorry the service turned out that way. You SHOULD have more than just your personal memories to leave a mark in the record books that you had a great life with Cindy. It doesn't help to say they can't take your memories, but it may help to chalk it up to their religious service and even though you don't subscribe to their religion you were being a big enough person to be there in support of Cindy's family. I wish they were able to offer you some emotional support too. Cindy's friends, your friends, the people that really know you as a couple think of you as a couple, in love, with a home and supportive relationship.

brooklyngirl said...

That's awful. I'm so sorry that you had to deal with that. In a way this blog and your recording of these experiences/ordeals is making/expanding your memories. But the whole lack of acknowledgement of your relationship with Cindy just sucks! Sorry.

Patty said...

Jenn, just because some people in Virginia Beach think differently, doesn't change the fact that Cindy was Emma and Leo's aunt, Cindy was my and Dom's sister in law, or that Cindy was our Mom and Dad's daughter in law. We have more than memories; we have pictures and videos. Please take solace that the Margiotta family has a different version of the last seven plus years. We're here for you now and always.

Anonymous said...

Oh, sweet Jen I am so very sorry. I'm not sure if these 40-day things are a Filipino custom, a Catholic custom, or both. I do know from my own experience with Kate's family that when it comes to Catholic death rituals, her family tends to go all out.

After Kate's cousin Charles (aka Chuckie) past away, there were several ceremonies within ceremonies during the wake and funeral period. Chuck's sister and his cousins and friends rallied together with a slide show and music to honor his spirit. However, some of the ceremonies were rather religious, which was SO not Chuckie. To be honest, I don't know how much input the family actually had in the content of these; I think the nuns (one of whom was quite zealous) and priests that were called in just took it upon themselves to run the show. I am hoping that is what occurred with Cindy's family. I would hate to think that her family willingly put those awful insensitive words into the priest's mouth.

Jen, no one can take away the fact that Cindy chose you, lived with you, LOVED YOU. I know this is a horrible blow after such a devasting loss. Take comfort in the support you do have from your own friends and family.

I read your blog everyday and you are in my prayers always.

Mateo_H said...

Ug. I don't know what to say except I don't know how it is that people who see the world the way we do are in the minority.

Annie, The Evil Queen said...

I have no words in the face of this. I'm so sorry you were ignored. There is no excuse for that.

Tyler said...

Your grace in this episode is certainly one of the things for which Cindy loved you and why she chose to make a permanent home with you.

Anonymous said...

What an unbelievable nightmare. I am enraged to think of your love for each other getting blotted out of the picture, as in ACTIVELY erased. Grrrrrrr...

What do we want? Equal rights. When do we want them? Already! PS. I now heart your family, too!

Anonymous said...

Aw Jennifer that really sucks. I'm sorry they couldn't show you the same effort that you showed them at the funeral. The Margiottas rock though!